That entryway often needs two different tools. Smart locks control access. Video doorbells add visibility at the porch. A host who needs both should treat them as separate jobs and buy accordingly. The picks below are arranged that way so you can match the hardware to the property instead of forcing one gadget to cover every front-door problem.
| Pick | Best for | Why it fits | Watch out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Schlage Encode Plus | One full replacement lock for the main front door | Keypad entry plus Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Apple HomeKit, and Apple Home Key keep guest access straightforward | It still depends on a door that closes and latches cleanly |
| August Wi-Fi Smart Lock | Rentals that must keep the outside hardware | Retrofits over the existing deadbolt and keeps the exterior look unchanged | Old deadbolt problems stay in the system |
| Yale Assure Lock 2 | Hosts who want a mainstream keypad on a tighter budget | A familiar deadbolt replacement with multiple trims for different setups | The wrong trim can leave out the connectivity you wanted |
| Ring Battery Doorbell Plus | Arrival visibility and delivery checks | Adds porch video without replacing the lock | It does not control entry |
| Arlo Essential Video Doorbell | A more polished front-door camera setup | Brings a stronger camera layer for busy or higher-end entryways | More alert management than a lock alone |
Schlage, Yale, and August are the access-control picks. Ring and Arlo are the visibility add-ons. If the property only needs one device, start with the lock. If the front door gets enough traffic that arrival proof or delivery monitoring changes how you manage the stay, add a camera after the lock is solved.
Schlage Encode Plus: Best overall
Schlage Encode Plus is the cleanest full-replacement pick for hosts who want one front-door lock that guests can use without learning anything new. The keypad keeps the check-in flow familiar, and Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, Apple HomeKit, and Apple Home Key support give the owner several ways to manage access without turning the door into a tech project. That matters when the same house has a mix of guests, from younger travelers who are comfortable with apps to older guests who would rather type a code and move on.
Best for: hosts who own the door and want a standard-looking deadbolt replacement that is easy to explain.
Why it helps: it handles the everyday rental workflow cleanly. Guests get in with a code, and the host gets a lock that fits into a broader smart-home routine without depending on a clumsy workaround.
Limitation: this is still a replacement deadbolt, so it assumes the door itself is in decent mechanical shape. If the latch drags or the strike plate is off, any smart lock becomes harder to live with.
Choose something else when: the exterior hardware cannot change, or when you want a lower-cost full replacement and are willing to sort through Yale’s trim choices.
Yale Assure Lock 2: Best value full replacement
Yale Assure Lock 2 is the better value play for hosts who want a mainstream keypad lock and do not need the Schlage nameplate or finish. It solves the same core Airbnb problem: give guests a code, keep the entry simple, and leave the host with an easy way to manage access. On the Wi-Fi trims, it also slides into a connected-home setup for hosts who want remote control without stepping up to a more expensive lock.
Best for: budget-conscious hosts who still want a familiar brand on the front door.
Why it helps: the lock does the part that matters most in an Airbnb, which is making entry obvious and repeatable. Guests do not need a tutorial, and the host does not need to explain a strange lock format over text at 11 p.m.
Limitation: Yale sells the Assure Lock 2 in multiple trims, so the wrong kit can leave out the connectivity or keypad style you expected. That is not a reason to avoid it, but it does make the buying choice more careful than it first looks.
Choose something else when: you want the most polished all-around replacement and are comfortable paying for Schlage, or when the outside hardware has to stay and you need August instead.
August Wi-Fi Smart Lock: Best no-drill option
August Wi-Fi Smart Lock is the right answer when the outside of the door has to stay exactly as it is. That makes it a strong fit for rentals, condos, and any property where the owner cannot replace the exterior deadbolt hardware. Because August works over the existing lock, the front of the door keeps the same look while the host gains smart access on the inside. That is the whole point of the product, and it is a good one for Airbnb setups that need flexibility without a visible hardware change.
Best for: no-drill installs and properties where the exterior hardware must remain untouched.
Why it helps: it solves the access problem without forcing a front-door makeover. A host can keep the existing keyway, preserve the property’s look, and still move to a code-based or app-based access flow.
Limitation: August inherits the old deadbolt, so any sticky action, worn cylinder, or sloppy alignment stays part of the experience. It adds control, not a mechanical reset.
Choose something else when: you want a fresh full replacement and a cleaner front-door look. In that case, Schlage or Yale is the better path.
Ring Battery Doorbell Plus: Best arrival-visibility add-on
Ring Battery Doorbell Plus is not a lock, but it belongs in an Airbnb roundup because a host often needs front-door visibility as much as access control. A battery doorbell camera helps you see arrivals, delivery drops, and who actually stood at the door during a check-in issue. For hosts already using Alexa, it fits naturally into the rest of the setup and gives the porch a simple camera layer without replacing the deadbolt.
Best for: hosts who want to see the door, not just unlock it.
Why it helps: it turns the front entrance into a place you can observe when a guest says they never found the door, a cleaner says they already arrived, or a package needs a quick look.
Limitation: it does not control entry. If the main problem is guest access, the lock comes first. A camera adds context, not a way inside.
Choose something else when: you only want one device and that device has to unlock the door. If the entry problem is access, Schlage, Yale, or August solves it better. If you want a more premium camera layer, Arlo is the next step.
Arlo Essential Video Doorbell: Best premium camera add-on
Arlo Essential Video Doorbell is the more polished camera pick in this group. It works best when the entryway is part of the guest experience and the front door needs to feel as intentional as the rest of the listing. The IP65 weather resistance makes it the stronger front-door camera choice here, especially if the porch is exposed and the camera has to live there full time.
Best for: hosts who want the camera to feel like part of a more deliberate front-door setup.
Why it helps: Arlo gives the porch a more complete video-doorbell role, which is useful when the entryway is a visible part of the property and you want the camera to match that level of care.
Limitation: like any doorbell camera, it adds another app layer and another set of alerts. That is fine if you want the visibility, but it is extra management compared with a lock alone.
Choose something else when: you want a simpler camera layer and do not need the extra polish. Ring is easier for a lot of Alexa-centered homes, and a smart lock is the better buy when camera footage is not the real need.
How to choose the right setup for an Airbnb
Start with the door, not the dashboard. If the deadbolt sticks, the strike plate is off, or the door does not close smoothly, fix that first. A smart lock cannot hide bad mechanics for long, and Airbnb guests are usually less forgiving of a front door that feels fussy.
Then decide whether you own the exterior hardware. If you do, a replacement deadbolt from Schlage or Yale is usually the cleanest path. If the building rules, lease terms, or the property itself keep you from changing the outside of the door, August is the better move because it works with what is already there.
After that, ask whether you truly need a camera. Ring and Arlo are useful when arrival visibility, package checks, or front-door proof solve a real problem. They are not substitutes for access control. A lock handles entry. A doorbell handles what happens at the threshold.
For guests, the simplest flow wins. Code first, app second. That matters for older guests, late check-ins, and anyone who does not want to install software just to open a door. It also matters for cleaners and co-hosts, because a simple access routine is easier to reset after every stay.
Keep the back end clean. Remove old codes after checkout, give cleaners and co-hosts their own access path, and replace batteries before they become a support call. Those habits do more for an Airbnb than a long feature list ever will.
Verdict
If you want one front-door answer that works for the widest range of Airbnb hosts, Schlage Encode Plus is the cleanest overall pick. It gives you a normal-looking replacement deadbolt, a guest-friendly keypad, and enough smart-home support to fit into a modern home without making the entry feel complicated.
If the property cannot swap exterior hardware, August Wi-Fi Smart Lock is the special-case winner. If the budget is tighter, Yale Assure Lock 2 is the value pick. If the real need is seeing the porch, Ring Battery Doorbell Plus is the simpler camera add-on, while Arlo Essential Video Doorbell is the more polished one.
For most hosts, the winning setup is a lock first and a camera only when it solves a real front-door problem. That is why Schlage stays the best all-around answer.